Ryan has been plagued with nightmares since the night his sister Amy went missing 8 years earlier after playing the game "Bloody Mary." Amy had stumbled onto a website on the Internet (www.marked4mary.com) about a witch called Bloody Mary and a game to summon her evil spirit. Now a senior in college, Ryan is reaching a mental breaking point from the years of stress and guilt from his sisters disappearance. His girlfriend Rachel frustrated herself at Ryan's emotional distance and self pity, calls for help to a former professor of Ryan's, Father O'Neal. Father O'Neal is both a priest and a archaeologist who decides to help Ryan end his tormenting grief by using his detective skills and wit to figure out what exactly happened to Ryan's sister, and uncover the truth to the Legend of Bloody Mary

内特（Paul Preiss 饰）打小就生活在单亲家庭之中，由母亲一手拉扯养大。如今，奈特已经长成了英俊强壮的真男人，并且即将和女友踏入婚姻的殿堂。一次偶然中，奈特结识了名为安迪（Bart Fletcher 饰）的男子，安迪个性桀骜不驯又无拘无束，相貌英俊个性开朗的他渴望能够在好莱坞寻得自己的一席之地。 就是这样两个性格与出身迥然不同的男人，两人之间竟然爆发出了惊人的吸引力，尽管内特对于内心中的真实情感百般抗拒，但最终他们还是跨越了伦理道德的界限。在此之后，内特通过安迪发现了一个惊人的秘密，这个秘密和曾经抛弃他和母亲的那个男人有着千丝万缕的联系。